Post by Sensei Justice on Apr 21, 2006 22:33:55 GMT -5
There has been much debate in recent history over the usage of Kata as a modern training took in the Martial Arts. In this article I will attempt to justify the importance of Kata not only to Karate, but to Martial Arts as a whole. Kate is the fundamental training method that can used by anyone at any time at any age and with as much individual freedom as one wishes to use. Therefore, making the Martial Arts an Art and not a Science.
Lets look at traditional Kata as taught in many of the traditional dojo’s. This is where many people see Kata as out dated and not of any major value in modern society. With that said I will make the argument now that Kata is more important in modern society than it ever was in pre-World War II society. Why you ask? In modern society hard-core training like they did 100 years ago is not possible. Many things factor into this such as lack of time, work, laws, and simply the fact you can’t afford to run students off by doing full contact sparring every class. What Kata gives Karate students is a way to fight without fighting, just as Bruce Lee said, “A way without way.” From my personal findings most people who attack Kata are non-karate stylists. Meaning they have never been taught the meaning and importance of forms. Anyone can memorize a set number of moves and put them together and call it a Kata but only a true Martial Artist can examine and break down those moves to find another way or meaning behind them. Kata is where the Martial Arts allow one to grow.
Unlike sparring you do not need anyone but yourself to do Kata. Kata can be done in a dojo, in your bedroom, outside or in your mind without actually moving. I can not recall the countless times I laid in bed or set in class thinking of how to prefect a combination in any given form. Questions such as: “Why did Funakoshi choose a back-fist over a punch?” or “What was he trying to tell me when he used a back stance with this hand motion?” Kata allows us to ask why and come to many of our own answers. There is no right and wrong there is only the TAO, or the way. Each of us must find our own way and Kata practice allows us to do that. When I do any from I can choose to do it slow and focus on techniques or I can speed it up and focus on my cardio training. All at the same time I am working many of my basic techniques while getting combination practice that I would get while sparring but now I am not getting hit.
Today many of the Mixed Martial Arts Community will attack Kata and say it is useless and outdated. What many of them fail to realize is that not all of us are training to fight. People participate in Martial Arts for many reasons: self-defense, exercise, social group, relaxation and yes: learning to fight. However, very few of us will ever dawn the gloves or step into the Octagon for a UFC. I completely understand if a person is training to become a great fighter they can easily overlook the importance Kata plays in their Martial Arts development. The problem here lies in the persons search for the quick and simple answer. For a true Martial Artist we know there is nothing simple about it and if you advance quickly then there is something to be said for your training methods but that is another article. So the question you are asking is does Kata make one a great fighter? The answer is it depends on that person. The question I am asking is does one have to be a great fighter to be a great Martial Artist? The answer to that is no! Although full contact fighters are grouped into Martial Arts they are not Martial Artists. Why? Because Art means it is personal. My Martial Art is different than yours regardless of our styles. Fighting is a science. Ask any boxer about the sweet science. I understand that people can have different styles of fighting and want to call it their own Art. However the human body can only do so many things. We only have 2 arms and 2 legs and they can only bend in one direction. So there is no room for expression in fighting, because we are all the same. However when you look at Kata you bring in the mind and that allows each of us to grow in our own way, thus making us Martial Artists.
Kata is a love hate relationship for most of us. Either you like it or you don’t. In my personal findings those who like it tend to understand its purpose. Those who dislike it only view it as a fixed pattern they must memorize for their next belt. Much too often as teachers we let students by with just memorizing the motions. This leads to low quality Black Belts down the road. Because they only focus on the physical and overlook the mental and spiritual aspects that are related to the Martial Arts. Just as I was making the point above when the mind enters into your training you develop the mental and spiritual aspect of Martial Arts. The physical part alone means you are a Martial Scientist. Art just like religion means we add the mental and spiritual aspect to our training. These two statements alone open up a can of worms that many have debated for years: the question of science vs. religion. Well let me sum it up this way. Both can lead to answers the only difference is religion makes it more personal, just as Kata makes Martial Arts more personal.
Kata can be done by anyone at any age at any time. This makes the Martial Arts one of the few exercises or hobbies that all of us can take part in. We don’t need a partner, we don’t even need a teacher (develop you own Kata). You defiantly don’t need a dojo or a gi. All you need is an open mind and willingness to learn. Kata is the fundamental aspect to any and all Martial Arts. Although one doesn’t have to excel in it to be a great fighter, one will need to spend some time shadow boxing. Or is that Kata, too?
Lets look at traditional Kata as taught in many of the traditional dojo’s. This is where many people see Kata as out dated and not of any major value in modern society. With that said I will make the argument now that Kata is more important in modern society than it ever was in pre-World War II society. Why you ask? In modern society hard-core training like they did 100 years ago is not possible. Many things factor into this such as lack of time, work, laws, and simply the fact you can’t afford to run students off by doing full contact sparring every class. What Kata gives Karate students is a way to fight without fighting, just as Bruce Lee said, “A way without way.” From my personal findings most people who attack Kata are non-karate stylists. Meaning they have never been taught the meaning and importance of forms. Anyone can memorize a set number of moves and put them together and call it a Kata but only a true Martial Artist can examine and break down those moves to find another way or meaning behind them. Kata is where the Martial Arts allow one to grow.
Unlike sparring you do not need anyone but yourself to do Kata. Kata can be done in a dojo, in your bedroom, outside or in your mind without actually moving. I can not recall the countless times I laid in bed or set in class thinking of how to prefect a combination in any given form. Questions such as: “Why did Funakoshi choose a back-fist over a punch?” or “What was he trying to tell me when he used a back stance with this hand motion?” Kata allows us to ask why and come to many of our own answers. There is no right and wrong there is only the TAO, or the way. Each of us must find our own way and Kata practice allows us to do that. When I do any from I can choose to do it slow and focus on techniques or I can speed it up and focus on my cardio training. All at the same time I am working many of my basic techniques while getting combination practice that I would get while sparring but now I am not getting hit.
Today many of the Mixed Martial Arts Community will attack Kata and say it is useless and outdated. What many of them fail to realize is that not all of us are training to fight. People participate in Martial Arts for many reasons: self-defense, exercise, social group, relaxation and yes: learning to fight. However, very few of us will ever dawn the gloves or step into the Octagon for a UFC. I completely understand if a person is training to become a great fighter they can easily overlook the importance Kata plays in their Martial Arts development. The problem here lies in the persons search for the quick and simple answer. For a true Martial Artist we know there is nothing simple about it and if you advance quickly then there is something to be said for your training methods but that is another article. So the question you are asking is does Kata make one a great fighter? The answer is it depends on that person. The question I am asking is does one have to be a great fighter to be a great Martial Artist? The answer to that is no! Although full contact fighters are grouped into Martial Arts they are not Martial Artists. Why? Because Art means it is personal. My Martial Art is different than yours regardless of our styles. Fighting is a science. Ask any boxer about the sweet science. I understand that people can have different styles of fighting and want to call it their own Art. However the human body can only do so many things. We only have 2 arms and 2 legs and they can only bend in one direction. So there is no room for expression in fighting, because we are all the same. However when you look at Kata you bring in the mind and that allows each of us to grow in our own way, thus making us Martial Artists.
Kata is a love hate relationship for most of us. Either you like it or you don’t. In my personal findings those who like it tend to understand its purpose. Those who dislike it only view it as a fixed pattern they must memorize for their next belt. Much too often as teachers we let students by with just memorizing the motions. This leads to low quality Black Belts down the road. Because they only focus on the physical and overlook the mental and spiritual aspects that are related to the Martial Arts. Just as I was making the point above when the mind enters into your training you develop the mental and spiritual aspect of Martial Arts. The physical part alone means you are a Martial Scientist. Art just like religion means we add the mental and spiritual aspect to our training. These two statements alone open up a can of worms that many have debated for years: the question of science vs. religion. Well let me sum it up this way. Both can lead to answers the only difference is religion makes it more personal, just as Kata makes Martial Arts more personal.
Kata can be done by anyone at any age at any time. This makes the Martial Arts one of the few exercises or hobbies that all of us can take part in. We don’t need a partner, we don’t even need a teacher (develop you own Kata). You defiantly don’t need a dojo or a gi. All you need is an open mind and willingness to learn. Kata is the fundamental aspect to any and all Martial Arts. Although one doesn’t have to excel in it to be a great fighter, one will need to spend some time shadow boxing. Or is that Kata, too?